In recent years, there’s been a growing interest in using charitable remainder trusts (CRTs) to avoid hefty tax payments and get more out of investments. This is especially true for people with appreciated assets, such as cryptocurrency, that they want to protect from capital gains tax. So, let’s delve into the nuances of CRTs and whether they make sense for crypto investors.

Understanding Charitable Remainder Trusts

Charitable remainder trusts come in a few different forms. Essentially, you take appreciated assets and place them into the trust. For instance, let’s say you bought $100,000 worth of Bitcoin several years ago, and it’s now worth $2 million. You could donate this appreciated Bitcoin to a CRT and receive a potential charitable donation credit for the $1.9 million gain.

Setup Complexity: Setting up a CRT involves a sophisticated process and requires professional help, usually from a lawyer and an accountant. Once the appreciated assets are in the trust, it will exist for a predetermined number of years, during which it pays out an amount to a designated beneficiary. However, it’s crucial to note that you only receive benefits from the interest or appreciation generated by the trust.

Avoiding Capital Gains Tax: One of the main attractions of a CRT is that it allows investors to avoid long-term capital gains tax on the appreciated assets. These taxes usually range from 15% to 20%, with an additional NIIT tax of 3.8%.

Here is an IRS webpage on Charitable Remainder Trusts.

Pitfalls and Risks

Despite these benefits, CRTs come with several downsides:

Annual Tax Requirements: Each year, you must file a tax return (Form 1041) for the trust using complex IRS calculations to prove its viability. Failure to meet these actuarial standards could lead to the trust unraveling, resulting in capital gains taxed on the entire amount, plus penalties.

IRS Scrutiny: Recently, CRTs have drawn significant attention from the IRS, labeling them as “listed transactions.” This means you must declare your involvement in a CRT on your personal tax return annually, turning it into an audit magnet. Once they see you have a “listed transaction”, there is a high likelihood that the crypto income will be audited as well. This rarely ends well.

Aggressive Assumptions: Many lawyers create CRTs with aggressive conditions, assuming high interest rates and appreciation. Often, the trust administrator sells assets upfront to invest in fixed-income assets. This could lead to issues where the trust fails to meet its beneficiary or charitable payouts, causing it to unravel.  Lawyers make money creating the trust, annual fees, and restructuring fees when the trust is about to unravel.

Regulatory Challenges

A notable challenge with CRTs is the stringent regulations that can limit their effectiveness. Investors may struggle to use the entire tax benefit due to income generation limits and other restrictions. Particularly, if you have significant gains but don’t generate enough income within five years, you might not be able to fully leverage the tax avoidance.

Conclusion: Approach with Caution

Given these complexities, it’s wise to approach CRTs with caution. They require careful navigation and compliance with numerous regulations. While they offer potential benefits, the risk of punitive action from the IRS and the likelihood of unraveling due to aggressive setups make them less appealing.

Final Advice: If you are considering a CRT, obtaining a second opinion from another tax professional or lawyer is strongly advised. This will ensure that you fully understand the implications and can make an informed decision.

Remember, this post is for informational purposes and not legal advice. For personal tax situations, consulting with a tax professional is recommended.

At CryptoTaxAudit, we provide expert guidance and essential resources tailored to your investment needs. Stay ahead of changing policies and ensure your financial decisions are well-informed and strategic.

Don’t miss out—schedule a call with us today equip yourself with essential knowledge to effectively manage crypto tax implications. Protect your financial future by acting now!

Related Articles:
Surviving an IRS Crypto Audit: Pro Tips from CryptoTaxAudit